| 2,029 | 11 | 321 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
在后工业化时代,越来越多的城市通过再开发闲置与废弃土地以及大型绿色基础设施建设工程,实现城市更新升级和“绿色转向”。《绿色绅士化——城市可持续发展与为环境正义而战》这一著作正是在这一背景下应运而生。本文从绿色绅士化的基本概念与内涵、生成机制和缓解策略三个方面对该书进行梳理,并对西方有关绿色绅士化的研究进展进行回顾和总结;在此基础上,从四个方面提出了该著作对我国未来绿色绅士化研究的启示:(1)检验绿色绅士化内涵的本土适用性;(2)评估我国城市绿色绅士化的表现和效应;(3)关注我国绿色绅士化的过程和机制;(4)提出解决我国城市绿色绅士化的路径。
Abstract:In the post-industrial era, more and more cities are upgrading and “greening” through the redevelopment of unused and abandoned land and largescale green infrastructure construction projects. The book Green Gentrification:Urban Sustainability and the Struggle for Environmental Justice written by Kenneth A. Gould and Tammy L. Lewis was published in this background.This paper combs and interprets the book from three aspects: the basic concept and connotation of green gentrification, generation mechanism and mitigation strategy of green gentrification. It also reviews and summarizes the research progress of green gentrification in the West. On this basis, the new trend of green gentrification research in China is proposed from four aspects:(1) testing the local applicability of the connotation of green gentrification;(2) evaluating the performance and effects of urban green gentrification;(3) focusing on the process and mechanism of green gentrification;(4) proposing pathways to solve the problem of urban green gentrification.
[1]LEES L.A reappraisal of gentrification:towards a ‘geography of gentrification’[J].Progress in human geography,2000,24(3):389-408.
[2]黄幸,杨永春.中西方绅士化研究进展及其对我国城市规划的启示[J].国际城市规划,2012,27(2):54-60.
[3]张海,卢松,饶小芳.西方绅士化研究进展及其对我国城市建设的启示[J].地理与地理信息科学,2020,36(1):121-128.
[4]HARVEY D.Justice,nature and the geography of difference[M].Oxford:Blackwell Publishing,1996.
[5]ANGUELOVSKI I,CONNOLLY J J,GARCIA L M,et al.New scholarly pathways on green gentrification:what does the urban ‘green turn’ mean and where is it going?[J].Progress in human geography,2018,43(1):1064-1086.
[6]GOULD K A,LEWIS T L.Green gentrification:urban sustainability and the struggle for environmental justice[M].New York:Routledge,2016.
[7]MAANTAY J,MAROKO A.Brownfields to greenfields:environmental justice versus environmental gentrification[J].International journal of environmental research and public health,2018,15(10):2233.
[8]ANGUELOVSKI I.From toxic sites to parks as(green)LULUs? new challenges of inequity,privilege,gentrification,and exclusion for urban environmental justice[J].Journal of planning literature,2016,31(1):23-36.
[9]RIGOLON A,NéMETH J.“We’re not in the business of housing:”environmental gentrification and the nonprofitization of green infrastructure projects[J].Cities,2018,81:71-80.
[10]RIGOLON A,STEWART W P,GOBSTER P H.What predicts the demand and sale of vacant public properties? urban greening and gentrification in Chicago[J].Cities,2020,107:102948.
[11]SCHROERING C.Review of green gentrification:urban sustainability and the struggle for environmental justice[J].Society&natural resources,2019,32(3):360-361.
[12]DOOLING S.Ecological gentrification:a research agenda exploring justice in the city[J].International journal of urban and regional research,2009,33(3):621-639.
[13]PHILLIPS M.Counterurbanisation and rural gentrification:an exploration of the terms[J].Population space and place,2010,16(6):539-558.
[14]ANGOTTI T.New York for sale:community planning confronts global real estate[M].Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press,2008.
[15]GOULD K A,LEWIS T L.The environment al injustice of green gentrification:the case of Brooklyn’s Prospect Park[M]//DESENA J,SHORTELL T,eds.The world in Brooklyn:gentrification,immigration,and ethnic politics in a global city.Lanham,MD:Lexington Books,2012:113-146.
[16]BERETTA I,CUCCA R.Ecological gentrification.a European perspective introduction[J].Sociologia urbana e rurale,2019(119):7-10.
[17]PEARSALL H,ANGUELOVSKI I.Contesting and resisting environmental gentrification:responses to new paradoxes and challenges for urban environmental justice[J].Sociological research online,2016,21(3):1-7.
[18]MULLENBACH L E,BAKER B L.Environmental justice,gentrification,and leisure:a systematic review and opportunities for the future[J].Leisure sciences,2018(1):1-18.
[19]PHILLIPS M,PAGE S,SARATSI E,et al.Diversity,scale and green landscapes in the gentrification process:traversing ecological and social science perspectives[J].Applied geography,2007,28(1):54-76.
[20]LITTKE H,LOCKE R,HAAS T.Taking the high line:elevated parks,transforming neighbourhoods,and the ever-changing relationship between the urban and nature[J].Journal of urbanism international research on placemaking&urban sustainability,2015,9(4):353-371.
[21]GOULD K A,LEWIS T L.Green gentrification and disaster capitalism in Barbuda[J].NACLA report on the Americas,2018,50(2):148-153.
[22]DOSHI S.Greening displacements,displacing green:environmental subjectivity,slum clearance,and the embodied political ecologies of dispossession in Mumbai[J].International journal of urban and regional research,2019,43(1):112-132.
[23]PARISH J.Re-wilding parkdale? environmental gentrification,settler colonialism,and the reconfiguration of nature in 21st century Toronto[J].Environment and planning e:nature and space,2020,3(1):263-286.
[24]BULLARD R D,ed.Confronting environmental racism:voices from the grassroots[M].Boston,MA:South End Press,1993.
[25]HARRIS B T.Fresh food,new faces:community gardening as ecological gentrification in St.Louis,Missouri[J].Agriculture&human values,2018,35(4):809-822.
[26]BLACK K J,RICHARDS M.Eco-gentrification and who benefits from urban green amenities:NYC’s high line[J].Landscape and urban planning,2020,204:1-14.
[27]IMMERGLUCK D,BALAN T.Sustainable for whom? green urban development,environmental gentrification,and the Atlanta Beltline[J].Urban geography,2018,39(4):546-562.
[28]BOCKARJOVA M,BOTZEN W,SCHIE M,et al.Property Price effects of green inter ventions in cities:a meta-analysis and implications for gentrification[J].Environmental science&policy,2020,112:293-304.
[29]DOSHI S.greening displacements,displacing green:environmental subjectivity,slum clearance,and the embodied political ecologies of dispossession in Mumbai[J].International journal of urban and regional research,2019,43(1):112-132.
[30]SOHN W,KIM H W,KIM J H,et al.The capitalized amenity of green infrastructure in single-family housing values:an application of the spatial hedonic pricing method[J].Urban forestry and urban greening,2020,49:126643.
[31]COLE H V S,MELISA T M,CONNOLLY J T,et al.Are green cities healthy and equitable? unpacking the relationship between health,green space and gentrification[J].Journal of epidemiology and community health,2017,71(11):1118-1121.
[32]IZENBERG J M,MUJAHID M S,YEN I H.Health in changing neighborhoods:a study of the relationship between gentrification and selfrated health in the State of California[J].Health and place,2018,52:188-195.
[33]PEARSALL H.From brown to green? assessing social vulnerability to environmental gentrification in New York City[J].Environment and planning c:government and policy,2010,28(5):872-886.
[34]MAIA A T A,CALCAGNI F,CONNOLLY J J T,et al.Hidden drivers of social injustice:uncovering unequal cultural ecosystem services behind green gentrification[J].Environmental science and policy,2020,112:254-263.
[35]BRANAS C C,KONDO M C,MURPHY S M,et al.Urban blight remediation as a cost-beneficial solution to firearm violence[J].American journal of public health,2016,106(12):2158-2164.
[36]CHAPPLE K,ZUK M.Forewarned:the use of neighborhood early warning systems for gentrification and displacement[J].Cityscape:a journal of policy development and research,2016,18(3):109-130.
[37]CHECKER M.Wiped out by the“green wave”:environmental gentrification and the paradoxical politics of urban sustainability[J].City and society,2011,23(2):210-229.
[38]CURRAN W,HAMILTON T.Just green enough:contesting environmental gentrification in Greenpoint,Brooklyn[J].Local environment,2012,17(9):1027-1042.
[39]DERCON S.Is green growth good for the poor?[J].Policy research working paper series,2012,29(2):74-94.
[40]ANGUELOVSKI I.Neighborhood as refuge community reconstruction,place remaking,and environmental justice in the city[M].Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press,2014.
[41]GOULD K A,LEWIS T L.From green gentrification to resilience gentrification:an example from Brooklyn[J].City and community,2018,17(1):12-15.
[42]SCHNAIBERG A,PELLOW D N,WEINBERG A.The treadmill of production and the environmental state[J].Research in social problems and public policy,2000,10(10):15-32.
[43]陈涛.美国环境社会学最新研究进展[J].河海大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2011(4):45-53,96.
[44]EICHHOLTZ P,KOK N,QUIGLEY J.Why do companies rent green? a model of ecological responsiveness[J].The academy of management journal,2009,434:717-737.
[45]ERNSTSON H.The social production of ecosystem services:a framework for studying environmental justice and ecological complexity in urbanized landscapes[J].Landscape and urban planning,2013,109(1):7-17.
[46]HARRIS B,RIGOLON A,FERNANDEZ M.“To them,we’ re just kids from the hood”:citizen-based policing of youth of color,“white space,”and environmental gentrification[J].Cities,2020,107:102885.
[47]ANGUELOVSKI I,CONNOLLY J T,MASIP L,et al.Assessing green gentrification in historically disenfranchised neighborhoods:a longitudinal and spatial analysis of Barcelona[J].Urban geography,2018,39(3):458-491.
[48]KRINGS A,SCHUSLER T M.Equity in sustainable development:community responses to environmental gentrification[J].International journal of social welfare,2020,29(4):321-334..
[49]HARVEY D.The right to the city[J].International journal of urban and regional research,2010,27(4):939-941.
[50]TOZER L,HRSCHELMAN K,ANGUELOVSKI I,et al.Whose city? whose nature? towards inclusivenature-based solution governance[J].Cities,2020,107(4):1-10.
[51]MILLER T J.Is urban greening for everyone? social inclusion and exclusion along the Gowanus Canal[J].Urban forestry and urban greening,2016,19:285-294.
[52]CURRAN W,HAMILTON T.Just green enough:urban development and environmental gentrification[M].New York:Routledge Press,2017.
[53]McKENDRY C,JANOS N.Greening the industrial city:equity,environment,and economic growth in Seattle and Chicago[J].International environmental agreements:politics,law and economics,2015,15(1):45-60.
[54]KRINGS A,SCHUSLER T M.Equity in sustainable development:community responses to environmental gentrification[J].International journal of social welfare,2020,29(4):321-334..
[55]WOLCH J R,BYRNE J,NEWELL J P.Urban Green space,public health,and environmental justice:the challenge of making cities ‘just green enough’[J].Landscape and urban planning,2014,125:234-244.
[56]RIGOLON A,NéMETH J.Green gentrification or ‘just green enough’:do park location,size and function affect whether a place gentrifies or not?[J].Urban studies,2020,57(2):402-420.
[57]CHEN Y,XU Z,BYRNE J,et al.Can smaller parks limit green gentrification?insights from Hangzhou,China[J].Urban forestry and urban greening,2021,59(1):1-19.
[58]史春云,陶玉国.城市绿地空间环境公平研究进展[J].世界地理研究,2020,29(3):621-630.
[59]何盼,陈蔚镇,程强,等.国内外城市绿地空间正义研究进展[J].中国园林,2019,35(5):28-33.
[60]楚晗.广州市环境绅士化研究[D].广州:广东工业大学,2020.
[61]王诗文.杭州市中心城区绿色绅士化问题研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2020.
[62]赵玉宗,顾朝林,李东和,等.旅游绅士化:概念,类型与机制[J].旅游学刊,2006,21(11):70-74.
[63]姚娜,李诚固,王梁.基于绿色消费观下的生态绅士化及其效应研究——以长春南溪湿地公园周边社区为例[J].现代城市研究,2019(3):19-27.
[64]洪世键,张衔春.租差、绅士化与再开发:资本与权利驱动下的城市空间再生产[J].城市发展研究,2016,23(3):101-110.
基本信息:
DOI:10.19830/j.upi.2021.308
中图分类号:TU984.113
引用信息:
[1]刘彬.西方绿色绅士化研究进展与启示——《绿色绅士化——城市可持续发展与为环境正义而战》述评[J].国际城市规划,2024,39(01):127-134.DOI:10.19830/j.upi.2021.308.
基金信息:
广东省创新强校工程2018年度项目(2018WTSCX203); 佛山市社科规划项目(2020-QN23); 吉林大学珠海学院创新能力培育工程2020年度项目(2020XJCQ028)
2021-08-16
2021-08-16
2021-08-16