| 1,017 | 5 | 286 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
随着“可持续发展”概念的提出，尤其是2001年可持续性科学的诞生，关于可持续社区的讨论逐渐成为诸多学科和领域关注的焦点。相较于社区可持续性评估国际研究的欣欣向荣，国内学界对该领域研究前沿的重视程度还有所欠缺。本文的主要内容包括：一是梳理国际研究对社区可持续性的定义，解析社区可持续性的内涵；二是开展SCI/SSCI数据库有关社区可持续性评估研究的文献计量，展示国际上社区可持续性评估研究的总体概况、主要学者、研究重点、研究主题演变及阶段划分；三是对中国社区可持续性相关概念和评估框架的本土化构建、发展机理、分类评估、规划范式以及治理方法库和政策集等五个方面进行展望。本研究希望为新时期我国社区可持续发展理论与实践探索提供科学参考和方向指引。
Abstract：With the proposal of the concept of “sustainable development”, especially the birth of Sustainability Science in 2001, the discussion of sustainable communities has gradually become the focus of many disciplines and fields. Compared with the booming international research on community sustainability assessment, the domestic academic circles still lack of attention to the research frontier in this field. This paper mainly includes the following three contents. Firstly, this paper reviews the definitions of community sustainability in international studies and analysis the connotations of community sustainability. Secondly, the bibliometric of community sustainability assessment research in SCI/SSCI database will be carried out to show the general situation, main scholars, research focus, research topic evolution and stage division of international community sustainability assessment research. Thirdly, the author prospect the localization construction, development mechanism, classification and evaluation,planning paradigm, governance method library and policy set of related concepts and assessment framework of community sustainability in China. It is expected to provide scientific reference and direction for the theoretical and practical exploration of community sustainable development in China in the new era.
[1]WCED.Our common future(the Brundtland Report)[M].Oxford,UK:Oxford University Press,1987.
[2]KATES R W.What kind of a science is sustainability science?[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2011,108(49):19449-19450.
[3]JERNECK A,OLSSON L,NESS B,et al.Structuring sustainability sciencel[J].Sustainability science,2011(6):69-82.
[4]KATES R W,CLARK W C,CORELL R W,et al.Environment and development,sustainability sciencel[J].Science,2001,292(5517):641-642.
[5]OLAIYA H B A.Transforming our world:the 2030 agenda for sustainable development&international decade for people of African descent[C].Meeting of ENAR Steering Group on Afrophobia,2016.
[6]NESS B,URBEL-PIIRSALU E,ANDERBERG S,et al.Categorising tools for sustainability assessment[J].Ecological economics,2007,60(3):498-508.
[7]PARRIS T M,KATES R W.Characterizing and measuring sustainable development[J].Annual review of environment and resources,2003,28(2):559-586.
[8]SHI J G,DUAN K F,WU G D,et al.Sustainability at the community level:a bibliometric journey around a set of sustainability-related terms[J].Sustainable development,2022,30(1):256-274.
[9]SHARIFI A,MURAYAMA A.A critical review of seven selected neighborhood sustainability assessment tools[J].Environmental impact assessment review,2013,38:73-87.
[10]MISCHEN P A,HOMSY G C,LIPO C P,et al.A foundation for measuring community sustainabilityl[J].Sustainability,2019,11(7):1903.
[11]KIDD C V.The evolution of sustainability[J].Journal of agricultural&environmental ethics,1992,5(1):1-26.
[12]BERARDI U.Sustainability assessment of urban communities through rating systems[J].Environment development and sustainability,2013,15(6):1573-1591.
[13]BOYKO C T,COOPER R,DAVEY C L,et al.Addressing sustainability early in the urban design process[J].Management of environmental quality,2006,17(6):689-706.
[14]VALENTIN A,SPANGENBERG J H.A guide to community sustainability indicators[J].Environmental impact assessment review,2000,20(3):381-392.
[15]MICHAEL F L,NOOR Z Z,FIGUEROA M J.Review of urban sustainability indicators assessment-case study between Asian countries[J].Habitat international,2014,44:491-500.
[16]HUNT D V,LOMBARDI D R,ROGERS C D,et al.Application of sustainability indicators in decision-making processes for urban regenerationprojects[J].Proceedings of the institution of civil engineers-engineering sustainability,2008,161(1):77-91.
[17]ALI-TOUDERT F,JI L M.Modeling and measuring urban sustainability in multi-criteria based systems:a challenging issue[J].Ecological indicators,2017,73:597-611.
[18]HUANG L,WU J G,YAN L J.Defining and measuring urban sustainability:a review of indicators[J].Landscape ecology,2015,30(7):1175-1193.
[19]EVANS J,JONES P.Rethinking sustainable urban regeneration:ambiguity,creativity,and the shared territory[J].Environment and planning a,2008,40(6):1416-1434.
[20]DOUGHTY M,HAMMOND G P.Sustainability and the built environment at and beyond the city scale[J].Building and environment,2004,39(10):1223-1233.
[21]BRIDGER J C,LULOFF A E.Toward an interactional approach to sustainable community development[J].Journal of rural studies,1999,15(4):377-387.
[22]PRESIDENCY U K.Bristol Accord[C]//Conclusions of Ministerial Informal Meeting on Sustainable Communities in Europe.Bristol,2005:6-7.
[23]TURCU C.In the quest of sustainable communities:a theoretical framework to assess the impact of urban regeneration[D].Calgary:University of Calgary,2009.
[24]WINSTON N.Sustainable community development:integrating social and environmental sustainability for sustainable housing and communities[J].Sustainable development,2022,30(1):191-202.
[25]BARR S,DEVINE-WRIGHT P.Resilient communities:sustainabilities in transition[J].Local environment,2012,17(5):l-8.
[26]MAYER A L.Strengths and weaknesses of common sustainability indices for multidimensional systems[J].Environment international,2008,34(2):277-291.
[27]李雪伟,王瑛.社会资本视角下的社区韧性研究:回顾与展望[J].城市问题,2021(7):73-82.
[28]SHARIFI A.Urban sustainability assessment:an overview and bibliometric analysis[J].Ecological indicators,2021,121(15):107102.
[29]DREYER L C,HAUSCHILD M Z,SCHIERBECK J.A framework for social life cycle impact assessment[J].International journal of life cycle assessment,2006,11(2):88-97.
[30]JORGENSEN A,LE BOCQ A,NAZARKINA L,et al.Methodologies for social life cycle assessment[J].International journal of life cycle assessment,2008,13(2):96-103.
[31]KLOEPFFERW.Life cycle sustainability assessment of products[J].International journal of life cycle assessment,2008,13(2):89-94.
[32]FOLKE C.Resilience:the emergence of a perspective for social-ecological systems analyses[J].Global environmental change-human and policy dimensions,2006,16(3):253-267.
[33]SMIT B,WANDEL J.Adaptation,adaptive capacity and vulnerability[J].Global environmental change-human and policy dimensions,2006,16(3):282-292.
[34]OSTROM E.A general framework for analyzing sustainability of socialecological systems[J].Science,2009,325(5939):419-422.
[35]REED M S,FRASER E D G,DOUGILL A J.An adaptive learning process for developing and applying sustainability indicators with local communities[J].Ecological economics,2006,59(4):406-418.
[36]REED M S,DOUGILL A J.Linking degradation assessment to sustainable land management:a decision support system for Kalahari pastoralists[J].Journal of arid environments,2010,74(1):149-155.
[37]SHARIFI A.A critical review of selected smart city assessment tools and indicator sets[J].Journal of cleaner production,2019,233(Oct.l):1269-1283.
[38]SHARIFI A,MURAYAMA A.A critical review of seven selected neighborhood sustainability assessment tools[J].Environmental impact assessment review,2013,38:73-87.
[39]SHARIFI A,MURAYAMA A.Neighborhood sustainability assessment in action:cross-evaluation of three assessment systems and their cases from the US,the UK,and Japan[J].Building&environment,2014,72:243-258.
[40]SHARIFI A,MURAYAMA A.Viability of using global standards for neighbourhood sustainability assessment:insights from a comparative case study[J].Journal of environmental planning and management,2015,58(1):1-23.
[41]HAAPIO A.Towards sustainable urban communities[J].Environmental impact assessment review,2012,32(1):165-169.
[42]JACOBSON S K.Evaluation model for developing,implementing,and assessing conservation education programs:examples from Belize and CostaRica[J].Environmental management,1991,15(2):143-150.
[43]MACLAREN V W.Urban sustainability reporting[J].Journal of the American Planning Association,1996,62(2):184-202.
[44]YUAN W,JAMES P,HODGSON K,et al.Development of sustainability indicators by communities in China:a case study of Chongming County,Shanghai[J].Journal of environmental management,2003,68(3):253-261.
[45]JEON C M,AMEKUDZI A.Addressing Sustainability in transportation systems:definitions,indicators,and metrics[J].Journal of infrastructure systems,2005,11(1):31-50.
[46]RANDALL T A,BAETZ B W.Evaluating pedestrian connectivity for suburban sustainability[J].Journal of urban planning and development,2001,127(1):1-15.
[47]AMEKUDZI A A,KHISTY C J,KHAYESI M.Using the sustainability footprint model to assess development impacts of transportation systems[J].Transportation research part a:policy and practice,2009,43(4):339-348.
[48]JIM C Y.Green-space preservation and allocation for sustainable greening of compact cities[J].Cities,2004,21(4):311-320.
[49]BLACKSTOCK K L,KELLY G J,HORSEY B L.Developing and applying a framework to evaluate participatory research for sustainability[J].Ecological economics,2007,60(4):726-742.
[50]LEE G K L,CHAN E H W.Factors affecting urban renewal in highdensity city:case study of Hong Kong[J].Journal of urban planning and development,2008,134(3):140-148.
[51]DE SOUSA C A.Turning brownfields into green space in the City of Toronto[J].Landscape and urban planning,2003,62(4):181-198.
[52]MAGIS K.Community resilience:an indicator of social sustainability[J].Society&natural resources,2010,23(5):401-416.
[53]KOWALTOWSKI D C C K,DA SILVA V G,PINA S A M G,et al.Quality of life and sustainability issues as seen by the population of low-income housing in the region of Campinas,Brazil[J],Habitat international,2006,30(4):1100-1114.
[54]PARKINS J R,STEDMAN R C,VARGHESE J.Moving towards local-level indicators of sustainability in forest-based communities:a mixed-method approach[J].Social indicators research,2001,56(1):43-72.
[55]FRASER E D G,DOUGILL A J,MABEE W E,et al.Bottom up and top down:analysis of participatory processes for sustainability indicator identification as a pathway to community empowerment and sustainable environmental management[J].Journal of environmental management,2006,78(2):114-127.
[56]RALL E L,HAASE D.Creative intervention in a dynamic city:a sustainability assessment of an interim use strategy for brownfields in Leipzig,Germany[J].Landscape and urban planning,2011,100(3):189-201.
[57]SCHADLER S,MORIO M,BARTKE S,et al.Designing sustainable and economically attractive brownfield revitalization options using an integrated assessment model[J].Journal of environmental management,2011,92(3):827-837.
[58]PEREZ M G R,LAPRISE M,REY E.Fostering sustainable urban renewal at the neighborhood scale with a spatial decision support system[J].Sustainable cities and society,2018,38(4):440-451.
[59]TEFERI Z,NEWMAN P.Slum regeneration and sustainability:applying the extended metabolism model and the SDGs[J],Sustainability,2017,9(12):2273-2289.
[60]MONTOYA J,CARTES I,ZUMELZU A.Indicators for evaluating sustainability in Bogota's informal settlements:definition and validation[J].Sustainable cities and society,2020,53:101896.
[61]COLE M J,BROADHURST J L.Measuring the sustainable development goals(SDGs)in mining host communities:a South African case study[J].The extractive industries and society,2021,8(1):233-243.
[62]ARSLAN T V,DURAK S,AYTAC D O.Attaining SDG11:can sustainability assessment tools be used for improved transformation of neighbourhoods in historic city centers?[C].Natural Resources Forum,2016.
[63]LANDORF C.Evaluating social sustainability in historic urban environments[J].International journal of heritage studies,2011,17(5):463477.
[64]CHAROENKIT S,KUMAR S.Environmental sustainability assessment tools for low carbon and climate resilient low income housing settlements[J].Renewable and sustainable energy reviews,2014,38:509-525.
[65]GAN X,ZUO J,WU P,et al.How affordable housing becomes more sustainable? a stakeholder study[J].Journal of cleaner production,2017,162:427-437.
[66]ANGUELOVSKI I,CONNOLLY J J T,MASIP L,et al.Assessing green gentrification in historically disenfranchised neighborhoods:a longitudinal and spatial analysis of Barcelona[J].Urban geography,2017,39(3):458-491.
[67]SAJJAD M,CHAN J C L.Risk assessment for the sustainability of coastal communities:a preliminary study[J].Science of the total environment,2019,671:339-350.
[68]SHARIFI A,DAWODU A,CHESHMEHZANGI A.Neighborhood sustainability assessment tools:a review of success factors[J].Journal of cleaner production,2021,293:125912.
[69]SHARIFI A,ALLAM Z.On the taxonomy of smart city indicators and their alignment with sustainability and resilience[J].Environment and planning b:urban analytics and city science,2021,49(5):1536-1555.
[70]ZHANG Y LI Q,WANG H,et al.Community scale livability evaluation integrating remote sensing,surface observation and geospatial big data[J].International journal of applied earth observation and geoinformation,2019,80:173-186.
[71]TURCU C.Re-thinking sustainability indicators:local perspectives of urban sustainability[J].Journal of environmental planning and management,2012,56(5):695-719.
[72]周兵兵,马群,邬建国,等.再论可持续性科学:新形势与新机遇[J].应用生态学报,2019,30(1):325-336.
[73]彭舒,陈军,任惠茹,等.面向SDGs综合评估的指标本地化方法与实践[J].地理信息世界,2022,29(4):48-55.
[74]王淑佳,孙九霞.中国传统村落可持续发展评价体系构建与实证[J].地理学报,2021,76(4):921-938.
[75]国家统计局.中华人民共和国2021年国民经济和社会发展统计公报[EB/OL].[2022-02-28].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2022-02/28/content_5676015.htm.
[76]杨俊宴,史北祥,史宜,等.高密度城市的多尺度空间防疫体系建构思考[J].城市规划,2020,44(3):17-24.
[77]FRITZ S,SEE L,CARLSON T,et al.Citizen science and the United Nations sustainable development goals[J].Nature sustainability,2019,2(10):922-930.
[78]柴彦威,于一凡,王慧芳,等.学术对话:从居住区规划到社区生活圈规划[J].城市规划,2019,43(5):23-32.
[79]陈寿松,翟国方,葛懿夫,等.基于QRH理念的传染病风险下社区治理与韧性提升研究[J].国际城市规划,2023,38(3):54-62.DOI:10.19830/j.upi.2020.719.
(1)检索公式为：TS=((“communit*”OR“neighbo*rhood*”) AND ((“sustainab*”OR“green”OR“low-carbon”OR“Eco”) NEAR/6 (“assess*”OR“evaluat*”OR“measur*”OR“rating”OR“ranking”OR“indicator*”OR“Index”)))，其中，“其S”表示“主题”，“*”表示模糊搜索，“NEAR/6”表示“两词之间距离单词数不大于6”。
(2)参考文献[28]使用Web of Science的过滤功能进行学科选择，剔除与社区可持续性关系不大的学科类型，只保留与社区可持续性相关的资源。剔除的学科类型详见参考文献[28]的补充材料。
基本信息:
DOI：10.19830/j.upi.2022.359
中图分类号:TU984.12
引用信息:
[1]秦书茜,张楠,朱佩娟,等.社区可持续性评估国际研究进展及中国展望[J].国际城市规划,2024,39(06):105-115.DOI:10.19830/j.upi.2022.359.
基金信息:
国家自然科学基金项目（42171202）; 湖南省社科基金重点项目（20ZDB034）
2022-06-20
2022
2024-11-29
2025-01-23
2025
3
2022-12-23
2022-12-23
2022-12-23