| 4,132 | 175 | 70 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
如何拯救深陷"收缩"困境的老工业城市,成为一项极具挑战性的任务。在当今西方国家的城市化进程中,受经济转型、资源枯竭、郊区化等诸多因素影响,一些传统老工业城市呈现出日益严峻的收缩现象,并引发一系列复杂的社会问题。基于全球化挑战—地方响应策略的理论分析表明,如何促进日渐"收缩"的老工业城市实现顺利转型,对长期以来增长管理为导向的城市规划传统理论提出了严峻的挑战,并且体现为全球化背景下,企业家主义或环境主义的地方响应范式之争。针对英国曼彻斯特和利兹的案例比较发现,尽管前者采取的企业家主义导向经济复兴战略加剧了经济增长与环境保护之间的矛盾冲突,但是后者尝试超越企业家主义范式的新探索带来了实现经济—环境双赢的新希望,且近年来可持续城市的理论探索也逐渐形成了新的发展方向。通过英国老工业城市转型的理论分析与实践比较,为我国的老工业城市发展转型提供了诸多的有益启示。
Abstract：How to save the shrinking cities becomes one of the most diffcult tasks in achieving sustainable urbanization. In the process of urbanization of the western countries, due to various factors such as economy transition, resource exhaustion, suburbanization and etc, many old industrial cities are lost in shrinking predicament which causes complex social problems. The theoretical analyzes from aspects of global challenges and local response shows that transition of shrinking cities has provoked the traditional urban planning theory focusing on growth management, which is reflected in the paradigm dilemmas between entrepreneurialism and environmentalism. The case studies of Manchester and Leeds in the UK demonstrate that although Manchester's renaissance strategic planning guided by entrepreneurialism paradigm led to increasing contradiction between economy growth and environment protection, Leeds' attempt to exceed traditional entrepreneurialism paradigm has brought about new prospect of integrating economy and environment issues, and that theory of sustainable cities also gives new chance to cope with problems of shrinking cities. The experiences of western shrinking cities can offer some guiding principles to old industrial cities' transition in China.
[1]Oswalt P,Rienitz T.Atlas of Shrinking Cities[M].Ostfldern:Hatje Crantz,2006.
[2]Oswalt P.Shrinking Cities.Vol.1:International Research[M].Ostfldern:Hatje Crantz,2005.
[3]Woolsey M.America’s Fastest-dying Towns[J/OL].Forbes.com.(2008-12-08)[2011-12-20].http://www.forbes.com/2008/12/08/towns-teneconomy-forbeslife-cx_mw_1209dying.html.
[4]Wiechman T.Between Spectacular Projects and Pragmatic Deconstruction[C].Paper Presented at Conference on the Future of Shrinking Cities:Problems,Patterns,and Strategies of Urban Transformation in a Global Context,2007.
[5]Pallagst K M.Das Ende der Wachstumsmachine[J].Berliner Debatte Initial,2007,18(1):4-13.
[6]Popper D E.Popper,F.J.Small Can Be Beautiful:Coming to Terms with Decline[J].Planning,2002,68(7):20-23.
[7]Hollander J B.Polluted and dangerous:America’s Worst Abandoned Properties and What Can be Done About Them[M].Burlington:University of Vermont Press,2009.
[8]Sachs W.Globalization and Sustainability[M]//Lechner,Boli.The Globalization Reader.Maldem:Blackwell,2004.
[9]彼得·霍尔,著.罗震东,耿磊,译.全球视角下的中国城市增长[J].国际城市规划,2009(1):9-15.
[10]彼得·霍尔,著.王士兰,王之光,译.长江范例[J].城市规划,2002(12):6-12.
[11]Jonas AEG,Ward K.A world of Regionalisms?Towards a US-UK Urban and Regional Policy Framework Comparison[J].Journal of Urban Affairs,2002(24):377-402.
[12]Peck,Tickell A.Neoliberalizing Space[J].Antipode,2002,34(3):380-404.
[13]Cunningham-Sabot E,Fol S.Schrumpfende Staedte in Westeuropa:Fallstudien aus Frankreich und Grossbritannien[J].Berliner Debatte Initial,2007,18(1):22-35.
[14]Cochrane A.Redefning Urban Politics for the Twenty-frst Century[M]//Jonas AEG,Wilson D.The Urban Growth Machine:Critical Perspectives Two Decades Later.Albany:State University of New York Press,1999.
[15]Low N,Gleeson B,Elander I,Lidskog R.Consuming Cities:The Urban Environment in the Global Economy After the Rio Declaration[M].London:Routledge,2000.
[16]Gibbs D.Ecological Modernization,Regional Economic Development and Regional Development Agencies[J].Geoforum,2000(31):9-19.
[17]Newman P,Thornley A.Urban Planning in Europe:International Competition,National Systems and Planning Projects[M].London:Routledge,1996.
[18]Girot C.Vers une Nouvelle Nature[M]//Kim A,Kohte M,Moll C.Landscape Architecture in Mutation-Essays on Urban Landscape.Zurich:gta Verlag,2005.
[19]Bridge G,Jonas AEG.Governing Nature:The Reregulation of Resource Access,Production and Consumption[J].Environment and Planning A,2002,34(5):759-766.
[20]Clark TN.Amenities Drive Urban Growth[J].Journal of Urban Affairs,2002,24(5):493-515.
[21]Short JR.Urban Imagineers:Boosterism and the Representation of Cities[M]//Jonas AEG,Wilson D.The Urban Growth Machine:Critical Perspectives Two Decades Later.Albany:State University of New York Press,1999.
[22]Keil R,Desfor G.Making Environmental Policy in Los Angeles[J].Cities,1996(13):303-315.
[23]Our Towns and Cities:The Future.Department for Communities and Local Government[R/OL],(2006)[2011-12-20].http://www.eukn.org/dsresource?objectid=153726.
[24]Williams G.Rebuilding the Entrepreneurial City:The Master Planning Response to the Bombing of Manchester City Centre[J].Journal of Environment and Planning B:Planning and Design,2000(27):485-505.
[25]Manchester City Council.The Manchester Community Strategy 2002-2012[R].Manchester City Council,Manchester,2002.
[26]Leeds City Council/Leeds TEC.The Leeds Economy Handbook 2000[R].Leeds City Council/Leeds TEC,Leeds,2000.
[27]Leeds Initiative.Vision for Leeds:A Strategy for Sustainable Development[R].Leeds Initiative,Leeds,1999.
[28]Leeds Initiative,Ove Arup&Partners.Sustainable Development Appraisal of Draft Leeds Vision II[R].Leeds Initiative,Leeds,2003.
[29]While A.The Environment and the Entrepreneurial City[J].International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,2004,28(03):549-569
[30]Office of the Deputy Prime Minister(ODPM).Cities,Regions and Competitiveness[R].OPDM,London,2002.
[31]Williams K.Achieving Sustainable Urban Form:Conclusions[M]//Williams K,Burton E,Jenks M.Achieving Sustainable Urban Form.London:E&FN Spon,2000:347-355.
[32]Whitehead M.Analysing the Sustainable City:Nature,Urbanization and the Regulation of Socio-environmental Relations in the UK[J].Urban Studies,2003,40(7):1183-1206.
[33]Holden M.Seeking Urban Sustainability on the World Stage[J].Habitat International,2008(32):305-317.
[34]Blanco H,Alberti M,Olshansky R,Chang S,Wheeler SM,Randolph J,London JB.Shaken,Shrinking,Hot,Impoverished and Informal:Emerging Research Agendas in Planning[J].Progress in Planning,2009(72):195-250.
基本信息:
中图分类号:TU984
引用信息:
[1]杨东峰,殷成志.如何拯救收缩的城市:英国老工业城市转型经验及启示[J].国际城市规划,2013,28(06):50-56.
基金信息:
辽宁省自然科学基金(2013020153);; 教育部人文社会科学基金(13YJCZH222);; 中央高校基本科研业务费人文社科科研专题(DUT12RW430)联合资助
2013-12-19
2013-12-19